View All Posts

Apr 25

Book Talk: "Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda" & "History Is All You Left Me"

Posted on April 25, 2018 at 3:45 PM by Amanda Davis

myAvatar (2)
Robert, Circulation Supervisor, Roswell Public Library, New Mexico

     Even though it seems like only recently that gay characters have started popping up in media, gay literature has a long history. Themes of tragedy, self-acceptance, and grief are common in gay literature, and it also provides representation to those who are looking for stories about people like themselves.
    In Becky Albertalli’s “Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda,” Simon juggles school work, drama club, and an active social life, like many other kids his age. He also comes from a middle class, close-knit family who would seem to accept him no matter what. Even though it seems that Simon is very privileged, he is still having a hard time coming out of the closet. In fact, the only two people who know that he’s gay are an anonymous Internet friend who he knows as Blue, and Martin, an acquaintance who happens upon an email from Blue when Simon forgets to log out of his account. Martin tells Simon that it’s no big deal that he’s gay, but he insinuates that the only way he will keep it a secret is if Simon invites him to get-togethers where Simon’s friend Abby will also be present. Simon is not thrilled with attempting to set up one of his best friends with a blackmailer, but he also wants to come out on his own terms. This book manages to evoke many of the same feelings gay people have had when deciding to come out, yet it does so in a way that keeps the reader hopeful that the book will reach a happy conclusion. It also inspires empathy. Many of the friends in Simon’s group get mad at each other and even stop talking to each other for some time, but they all make an attempt to understand each other, making it a welcome relief for those looking for a book without petty drama.
    Grief is a universal human emotion, as shown in Adam Silvera’s “History Is All You Left Me.” Griffin’s best friend (and ex-boyfriend), Theo, dies tragically, with the only other person able to understand him being Jackson, Theo’s boyfriend at the time of his death. Griffin’s inability to open up to friends and family, compounded by the difficulties of obsessive-compulsive disorder, almost leaves Griffin in a stagnant, grief-stricken state that takes a lot of introspection to recover from. This book seamlessly transitions between past and present, taking readers through Griffin’s journey as he falls in love with Theo and overcomes his heartache from Theo’s death. Unlike many other stories that have characters with mental illness, Silvera handles the subject of a person living with obsessive-compulsive disorder with sensitivity. Griffin is presented as a real person with actual struggles and is never reduced down to a two-dimensional trope. He does a great job of representing gay people as having the same needs and feelings as everybody else. “History Is All You Left Me” can be found in Young Adult Fiction.